Two unlikely worlds collide in The Taste of Ashes, a story of redemption and the resilience of the human spirit, even at its most frail and vulnerable.
Isabel Lee’s early life in rural BC was forever changed by a brief but powerful love affair with a young priest. Now a recovering alcoholic, Isabel struggles to pull the tattered fragments of her life together and repair the damage to her relationship with her estranged daughter.
Once idealistic and hopeful, Father Àlvaro Ruiz now has his own demons to confront. Brutally tortured at the hands of the Guatemalan authorities and unable to escape the wounds of his past, Àlvaro returns to Canada seeking sanctuary, a broken man with a tenuous grip on his faith in God and humanity.
Isabel’s and Àlvaro’s stories slowly weave together and they are eventually faced with their greatest challenge yet: can they carry on in the wake of the damage and bring themselves to forgive? Compelling, disturbing but ultimately hopeful, this is the story of how we find grace in the most unexpected places.
Caitlin Press 2012
Trade paperback, 272 pages
Ebook available at:
Reviews and Reflections
From Ev Bishop in Write here, write now
The Taste of Ashes by Sheila Peters reads more like non-fiction about actual living, breathing individuals and literally true events, than well-researched fiction that’s “merely” emotionally true. By praising it or raving about how much I enjoyed it, I feel I’m making light of real people’s very difficult, hard circumstances. Likewise, if I criticize any part, I feel I’m somehow slamming real people—and how dare I do that?
But I did enjoy it. Identified with it. Laughed out loud in places. The story’s written in a braided narrative, with three main point-of-view characters: Isabel Lee, one-time wild child, now recovering alcoholic and fodder for the small town rumour mill, Father Álvaro Ruiz, a priest seeking respite in Canada after enduring mind, body and spirit breaking torture in Guatemala, and Janna—Isabel and Álvaro’s daughter, born out of an intense affair the first time Álvaro was in Canada as a young Oblate priest—a child Álvaro knows nothing about. Once their voices were established and I knew who was who, I could hardly put the book down—though at times, out of stress, outrage and empathy, I wanted to throw it across the room.
From Margaret Thompson in BC Bookworld
The Taste of Ashes is a redemption song about the resilience of the human spirit. To read the full review…
From Caroline Woodward in Woodward on Words
This is a thoughtful and well-written novel which will challenge those in ‘comfortable pews’ as well as those readers who try to avoid reading about genocide (in this case, Guatemala) or those who have set ideas about Catholic priests. This is to name just three good reasons to read this challenging book. To read the full review…
From Book Club Buddy
From Nicole Larson at the Books and Co Blog
Sheila Peters’s novel, The Taste of Ashes, does not feel like a first novel. It’s carefully crafted, multi-layered family narrative is complex and lyrical in a way that reveals Peters’s history as a poet and short-story writer. The three primary narratives that follow Isabel, Álvaro and Janna’s individual stories are interwoven in such a way that even a few convenient coincidences – which could have seemed contrived and artificial – feel genuinely spontaneous and natural.
Each of the three main characters, Isabel, Álvaro and Janna, is flawed and complicated, but ultimately sympathetic. Isabel, the heart of the novel, is a study in duality. Her sensuous – in the most literal sense of the word – nature makes her an excellent mother when she is present, but also causes her to frequently fall off the rails and into the arms of random men. Because we meet her after she’s sobered up and calmed down, her rift with Janna seems unfair and undeserved, but as we learn what ultimately precipitated their separation, Isabel becomes a more complete, if not more likeable character.
Álvaro’s history is the most complex and his broken psyche and body, the result of brutal torture at the hands of Guatemalan authorities, are what bring The Taste of Ashes out of the realm of the ordinary. Peters’s masterful description of the aftermath of torture, the anger and shame and fear that Álvero still feels creates a character that readers will find both frustrating and sympathetic. His interactions with the other priests in his brotherhood, his questions about faith and God’s role in his life and the stages of his healing are fascinating and have an air of authenticity.
Suggested Book Club questions
(thanks to the Booklore Book Club members for their contributions)
- This is a novel about families and family secrets. When should secrets be kept and when should they be revealed? How important is it that people know who their biological parents are? Are there circumstances when it’s best they aren’t told?
- What kind of mother is Isabel? Are her actions forgivable? Should her children have been removed from her care? Does her recovery ring true?
- How do Janna’s and Álvaro’s journeys parallel each other?
- How does Isabel’s life parallel that of Álvaro’s mother?
- The turbulent politics of Guatemala and the resulting violence have an important role in this novel. How does the impunity of those with power in Guatemala compare between with those who have power in Canada? In what ways do Isabel, Álvaro and his mother resist the forces moving against them? In what ways do they succumb?
- How and why did Isabel retreat to her garden? What did gardening do for her?
- We read about rituals, some deeply rooted in a specific culture, others created by Isabel, Janna, and others. Do the rituals people make up for themselves fulfill the same purpose as more traditional ones?
- What meaning does the title evoke?
- Walter is a strong character who could be said to represent some of the worst characteristics of the Catholic Church? What are those characteristics and how did you respond to them? How is he a positive force?
- What part does religious or spiritual belief play for the novel’s characters? How do the indigenous cultures and the Catholic culture compare?
- What clothes people choose to wear can reveal a lot about them. What role does clothing play in this novel?
- The novel portrays young people in various stages of life. How do they differ? What do they reveal about each other? What role does Amy play? Dustin?